Weather Bureau Models – Not Very Good

Tropical Storm Isaac started out in the Atlantic Ocean, and crossed over into the Caribbean Sea. The NOAA models projected that Florida was in the path. With the Republican National Convention scheduled to run at the same time as the soon to be hurricane, the news media was awash with speculation on what would happen.

Of course, by the time that Isaac pulverized Haiti and Cuba, running over the Florida Keys, the models were forecasting that the path might be a little west of the original guesses.

After another day, the models were moving the probable path even further west. Over the weekend, the forecasted path had moved from the coast of Florida, to Alabama, to Mississippi, to Louisiana. Now, that grand old town, New Orleans, is being named to a rematch with mother nature as Isaac is supposed to hit there.

So, what is going on?

The government’s hurricane models are virtually worthless. A given hurricane path forecast is almost always wrong, and they have to correct their forecasts after the storm has gone in another direction. You can do almost as well by testing the direction of the wind with a wet finger.

There are a few things you need to know about models. This includes weather forecasting models, hurricane models, and climate models. There is a little understood fact in that they are all MODELS, and not actual, accurate representations of the systems they seek to study.

All models are built upon what we think we know, what we can measure, and a lot of assumptions about those things of which we don’t have a good understanding. For decades climatologists have thought that carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas, is a primary driver of climate. As things turn out, carbon dioxide levels have increased dramatically in the last dozen or so years, and the world’s average temperature has changed little, if any at all.

This is one reason why none of those eighteen or twenty climate model used around the world have never made a correct forecast. The government’s weather and hurricane models suffer from similar problems. It is currently impossible to accurately represent the weather system mathematically.

When you wonder why those guys never get it right, remember that they, too, need their jobs. A government climate or weather modeler has job security, and they don’t even have to be right.

What a country!

4 thoughts on “Weather Bureau Models – Not Very Good”

  1. Well, I hope you are correct. But from the looks of things, Isaac is coming to wreck havoc. And from I have heard on the radio the liberal protesters are already causing and wrecking havoc during the GOP convention.

  2. No one is as smart as Mother Nature. She will do what she wants to do, when she wants to so it, because she wants to do it. Gut, man keeps trying to understand her and out smart her. On the positive side, the national Weather Bureau does seem to know their limitations and therefore warn a large enough area that no one in any potential storm path has an excuse not to be prepared.

  3. Well, Isaac is stalled outside of New Orleans, and my Mississippi cousins in the Gulfport area have a problem. I don’t think they will lost their homes like they did during Katrina. My prayers are for all those folks.

  4. I agree about nature will do what nature will do. Maybe some day we will have a better understanding of how things work, but I don’t think we are anywhere near that, now.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.